• Česky
  • Contacts
  • Faculties and other parts
    Czech University of Life Sciences Prague
    Faculties and institute
    • Faculty of Economics and Management
    • Faculty of Agrobiology, Food and Natural Resources
    • Faculty of Engineering
    • Faculty of Environmental Sciences
    • Faculty of Forestry and Wood Sciences
    • Faculty of Tropical AgriSciences
    • Institute of Education and Counselling
    Other parts & departments
    • Library
    • Department of Physical Education (KTV)
    • Division of information and communication technologies
    • Accommodation & Meals
    • CZU Farm Estates
    • CZU Forests
    • CZU Winery
Facebook Youtube Instagram
Faculty of Forestry and Wood Sciences
  • About Faculty
  • Departments
  • Study
  • Science & Research
    • Research profile
    • Staff outputs
    • Conferences
    • Doctoral Study
    • Documents
    • Internal grants
    • Academic Qualifications
  • International Relations
  • Projects and partnerships
  • About Faculty  
    • Faculty Management
    • Faculty Authorities
    • Academic Senate
    • Official documents
    • Faculty activities
  • Departments  
    • Departments and excellent teams
    • Faculty units
  • Study  
    • Study at FLD
    • Study Now
    • Information for Students
    • Study Documents
    • Admission Procedures
    • Study Administration Office
  • Science & Research  
    • Research profile
    • Staff outputs
    • Conferences
    • Doctoral Study
    • Documents
    • Internal grants
    • Academic Qualifications
  • International Relations  
    • General information
    • International cooperation
    • International mobility – Erasmus+
    • Study Programmes in English
    • Documents & forms
  • Projects and partnerships  
    • Department for Development
    • Projects
    • Cooperation with schools
    • Applied outputs
    • Partnership
  1. FLD
  2. Science & Research
  3. Staff outputs
  4. Popularization of Science
  5. Is European forest management sustainable?

Is European forest management sustainable?

Not in most current forests. This is almost the only statement agreed by scientists across Europe in a recent exchange of views in the prestigious journal Nature. Miroslav Svoboda from the CULS Faculty of Forestry and Wood Sciences was among those who were allowed to comment on the original text. What was it about?

Climate change is forcing adaptation. Those who do not adapt must get off the bike. This applies to both social and natural systems. However, with a properly set up functioning of the social system, the natural order can also benefit. This is one of the EU's goals, which in its 2020 biodiversity strategy calls for forestry approaches that lead to the protection of species and habitats. In addition, the EU also targets a lower carbon footprint.

Against this background, the Italian-Finnish team led by Sylvan Fares presented a set of recommendations that should ensure greater forest resilience while increasing carbon sequestration.

In their view, tree species that can adapt to changing climatic conditions should be grown in Europe's forests. Ie. tree species that are primarily drought-resistant, regardless of whether they are native species. They also recommend more intensive thinning and shortening the rotation period time, ie. forest management in a shorter production cycle. Their last recommendation is to regulate and control natural disturbances, such as storms or fires, in order to ensure greater stability of forest stands. Fares and the team also pointed out that currently only 2/3 of the annual growth of European forests is harvested, which means a loss in terms of bioenergy production.

The reactions did not take long, and the editorial staff of Nature received independently of each other critical comments from four traditionally forestry countries.

Opponents pointed to the necessity to understand the forest as a complex ecosystem, not just as a timber plantation reduced to an engineering unit with measurable inputs and outputs. Forests in the EU have several other functions, such as protecting forest-dependent organisms and their habitats or tourism. They emphasize that the publication does not distinguish between intensively managed forests for timber production and forests that also provide other functions. At the same time, they warn against similar tendencies, which, under the auspices of the fight against climate change and a carbon-balanced Europe, are proposing solutions that have the effect of maximizing logging.

Miroslav Svoboda adds: “Absolute control of the forest is expensive and inefficient. Rather than interventions against natural processes, sensitive interventions in their direction can contribute to adaptation to climate change.” His words are supported by several studies that have addressed this issue, reaching the following conclusions:

  • Forest management aimed only at maximizing wood production leads to the loss of native tree species and other organisms that live in the forest. At the same time, the tourist and social function of the forest, which in the EU provides similar or higher financial returns than forestry, is significantly limited.

  • Reducing the rotation period and removing rotting wood threatens old forests and old trees that represent the homes of many birds, bats, beetles, mushrooms and lichens.

  • It is necessary to distinguish between forests intended mainly for economic functions and forests that also have other functions.

Many generations of foresters in European forests have tried to reduce disturbances. The result is a tripling of the amount of wood that has fallen in Europe over the last 40 years as a result of wind, bark beetle or fires. In addition, examples from the USA show that the suppression of disturbances (specifically fires) leads to a smaller number of events, but these are much more intense as a result. From this point of view, the fight against the natural order of the forest seems uneconomical, the results are usually exactly the opposite of what was intended. Not to mention the impact on biodiversity.

The challenge facing European forestry is demanding: to ensure wood production and carbon sequestration, all without compromising biodiversity and other social functions of the forest. It is undeniable that this task remains far more important than any academic skirmish. However, we can be pleased that a voice from the FLZ CULS was heard in a prestigious periodical such as Nature. Less so, that there is such a fundamental contradiction in the approach to management, which covers almost 40% of Europe's area.

Jonsson, B.G, Peer, G., Svoboda, M. (2015): Forest: not just a timber plantation. Nature 521, 32.

 

Prof. Ing. Miroslav Svoboda, Ph.D. (* 1977)

Prof. Svoboda studied forestry at the Faculty of Forestry and Wood Sciences, CULS in Prague. He became an associate professor in the field of ecology in 2009 at the CULS FES and obtained a professorship at the CULS FFWS in the spring of 2015. He currently works as the head of the youngest department - forest ecology - at the FFWS.

 

Prepared by: Jiří Lehejček

Faculties and Other Parts

  • Faculty of Economics and Management
  • Faculty of Agrobiology, Food and Natural Resources
  • Faculty of Engineering
  • Faculty of Environmental Sciences
  • Faculty of Forestry and Wood Sciences
  • Faculty of Tropical AgriSciences
  • Institute of Education and Counselling
  • Department of Physical Education
  • Library
  • Halls of Residence & Refectory
  • Department of Information and Communication Technologies

Links

  • Study Applicants
  • Students
  • Alumni
  • Partners
  • Public

Contact Information

Czech University of Life Sciences Prague (CZU)
Kamýcká 129
165 00 Praha - Suchdol
Czech Republic
VAT number: CZ60460709
Tel.: +420 224 381 111
GPS coordinates: 50,129976, 14,373707
 

PIC: 999912570
OID: E10209207
DUNS: 360576495


Information presented on this server may only be published upon explicit agreement from CZU Prague.
Information on CZU Processing and Protection of Personal Data.
© 2024 Czech University of Life Sciences Prague
All rights reserved

English ☰ Menu

We use cookies on the web presentations of the Czech University of Life Sciences Prague (under the czu.cz domain). These files give us ways to serve our services better and help us analyze site performance. We can share information about how you use our sites with our social media, advertising, and analytics partners. In the settings, you can choose which cookies we can use. You can change or revoke your consent at any time.

Cookie settings customization
We use cookies on the web presentations of the Czech University of Life Sciences Prague (under the czu.cz domain). These files give us ways to serve our services better and help us analyze site performance. We can share information about how you use our sites with our social media, advertising, and analytics partners. In the settings, you can choose which cookies we can use. You can change or revoke your consent at any time.
Essential cookies
These cookies are essential for the proper functioning of the website. They ensure the correct display, submission of forms, and without these cookies, we cannot provide you with services on our website.
Analytical and statistical cookies
We use this type of cookies to evaluate the traffic and performance of web presentations, e.g., how many people visit the presentation, in what frequency, what information you are looking for, which you do not find and which information is most important. Based on this data, we can improve the content and thus improve the services and information we offer.
Advertising cookies
Our partners use advertising cookies to display relevant advertising based on your preferences.